长篇影评
1 ) Finally, we are the leftovers.
尽管这部剧节奏慢的要死,但是,却充满了让人欲罢不能的感动。
S02E01
如果没有Matt在30几分钟的时候出场,我一度以为自己看了一部假的《守望尘世》。还有主角怎么可以再47分钟的时候才出场嘞?
第一季结尾,本以为父女俩手牵手,母子俩手牵手,最后会是个四口之家团聚的结局,而Nora会领养小孩后,重新生活,没想到啊,真是没想到啊!
S02E03
有时候,有些坎儿可能永远都迈不过去。我们能做的只是让时间把它一点一点磨平,但永远抹不去。看到Laurie在出版商面前时空的样子,让我想起了《胡丽叶塔》里相似的情节。遗忘不是永恒。
S02E05
虽然不了解基督教的文化,但当Matt代替那个被架在车顶的人的时候,我开始相信耶稣被钉在十字架上的事情了。
S02E06
当所有的不切实际遇到一起的时候,即使他显得更加不切实际,但我们也得接受这种不切实际额了。
女人的直觉好准。
S02E07
一日夫妻百日恩,最后都融情于血了。
S02E08
理解至上。所有症结皆有源。
有时候不是生活困住了我们,是我们自己困住了自己。但有时候不是自己逼着自己,是生活逼着我们。
S01E09
This is such a small world.
有时候,我们生活里缺的可能仅仅是信念本身,无论这所谓的信念假借于什么,只要他存在,我们就好像有了某种支柱一般。
行走在这个世界当中,就像是在和各种信仰斗争的一个过程,你选择的,你坚持的,你抛弃的,你反抗的,总之,总得给自己找点儿事做。
S02E10
美国家长心真大,大半夜的就敢让三个女高中生开车去游泳?Are you kidding me?
三个女生到达水库的时间节点与Kevin到水库自杀的时间有些问题啊,不管怎么说也不可能同时到达了,那就更别提提前到了。一个人梦游,发生了时空穿越?
为什么电视剧里非得有几个这种傻—角色呢?
信仰攻占地球。
无知是生活对我们最大的嘲讽。
Kevin的生活就是我们每个人的生活,真实。
2 ) 记录想法
- 一个怀疑:大写的FAMILY越来越变成这剧的中心了,剧集都以family为单位,什么都围绕着美国中产阶级郊区别墅转,大家的终极目标都是回归到这一个形态的family里。第一季里更丰富的人物关系像是同事朋友同学以及基本没有的同性家庭都没了,甚至还会出现Nora那集里NYC的城市景象吗,感到怀疑。实话说这不都是heteronormativity的一部分吗¯\_(ツ)_/¯这样搞也太单调了 (我还是要和Patti站在一起说there is no family
3 ) 剧变之后,我们如何救赎
不要让宗教的外衣,让你将《守望尘世》拒之门外。
这里所讨论的,更多的是,除了衣食住行的物质需求外,为何唯有信仰才能支持我们度过余生。
当遭遇生活剧变、及面临由此带来的恐惧时,你会作何反应?试图去解释、去理性化,又或者是将其抛诸脑后?
有人在这种剧变里找到了自己的使命感,有人只想忘却一切重新开始。
生活突变本身并没有对错,我们据此所作出的回应也没有对错之分。
但在剧变面前,我们早前所以为理所当然的希望,全部都变得虚渺和不现实。
希望,变成了一种我们可望而不可求的奢侈品。
剧变所带来的不仅仅是对未知的恐惧,同时还伴随着某件事/某个人逝去的悲伤。眼前的悲伤如此之强烈,以至于坚信这种悲伤在未来仍然是无法消除的无力感,让你觉得只有活在无法挽回所失的悲痛当中,才是继续与所失温存的唯一出路。
很喜欢 Holly Wayne 对 Nora 说的一段话:
You believe that you will always feel that pain
And it starts to slip away, you seek it out again
Didn't you?
You won't let it kill you, but you won't kill yourself.
坚信,痛感常在
但当悲伤渐行渐远
你却不自主地,撕开伤疤
悲痛,不会令人致死
受苦人却总难自断
or whoever is joined with all of the living, there is hope.
Surely, a live dog is better than a dead lion.
Hope, is your weakness.
You want it gone because you don't deserve it.
Nora, you do deserve hope.
孕育于生命
活狗胜死狮
隐含着脆弱
无求即失去
凡人皆可得
希望
此时,能够提供一个使命感给你的人,都可以轻易地控制忙于疗伤的你,这就是为什么剧里 Guilt Remnant 可以大行其道的原因。
他们为所有失去亲人、面对剧变前不知所措的人提供了一个明确的使命感,这种使命感是对还是错,对于迷茫、一无所有的他们来说,并不重要。
G.R.为他们提供了一个信仰去相信、去坚持,即使这个信仰在外人看来是多少的可笑可怜。
甚至你们可以将这种行为以宗教来解释,只不过后者经历了千年的磨炼,有了系统的准则、故事和事例去完善这一份信仰。
目前有两个情节非常震撼人心,第一个是第一季末 G.R. 所发起的“集体回忆录”行动,将所有 Departed People 在现场还原成人偶,Nora 的演员演技大爆发,直到最后的全民围攻G.R.总部,他们的这种坚信“悲痛不可忘”的信仰令他们已完全忘记自身行为的对或错,以及对于别人造成的伤害。
你会诧异于为何人会无情至此做出如何残忍之事,“集体回忆录”行动所带来的伤害,某种程度上比 Departure 本身更大。
疯狂只是假象,正是剧中多次描述的“丛林疯狗”一样,你觉得它们是因为 Department 而发疯,但其实也许仅仅是外来的野狗而已。
你若悉心照料与培养,一样还是能够与你共存。
重点是,你选择走什么样的道路去继续生活。
另外一个是第二季第3集末 Laurie & Tommy 的对话,Laurie 问了一个终极的问题:
Why are we losing?
当你将人的原本信仰清空而不灌输新的信仰,就会发现,失去生活重心的人是最为危险的,你也没有办法让他们重新回归正轨。
人若没有了信仰,要不如行尸走肉般生活毫无生气,要不寻求终极解脱。唯有以信仰抵抗信仰,才能在这场迷茫的人生战场上紧握胜券。
若第一季的主题是信仰迷失混战,第二季的主题就是新信仰的燃起。
这剧真的需要慢慢看~~~~~
#部分评论来自公众号 DramaMatters#
4 ) A new but weird start 第一集影评
第一季的结尾,几张饱经风霜的脸上终于都露出了笑容,已经碎成无数片的生活,终于又一点一点被粘合了起来,新的一季,新的故事,就将在这个被称为miracle的小镇开始。
从这个小镇的名字,以及种种细节,我们不难推测出,“十月四日消失事件”对它没有影响,所有居民都留了下来,这也让它成为了又一个精神上的符号——就如同黑先知、GR等等。外界的人们一批批地进入,只为一个纪念品、一个护身符,甚至连水也可以成为商品。一个个被消失事件深深伤害的人,都渴望从这个圣地抓住一丝一毫的安全感。
然而,这个小镇并没有表面看上去那样和善光明。John只因认为别人咒他倒霉,就直接烧了他的房子(而且他没有什么朋友来参加他的生日聚会,他还能直接地,若无其事地对一个陌生人说自己蹲过监狱),从他们对level的分级上看,这样的事情他们已经干过很多次,很熟练了,而且Issac并没有报警之类的意图,居然就这样让这件事过去了。
小镇里还有其他许多的奇怪之处:一个一直住在塔上的老人;一个人很不礼貌地打断Matt神父的讲话,好像不想听他讲他的经历;路上的裂缝(可能是频繁的地震的结果);穿着婚纱浇花的人;以及最诡异的,一夜之间干掉的池塘和Evie的神秘失踪。
还有两个细节,一是John听到的蟋蟀或蛐蛐之类昆虫的叫声,可能类似于第一季Kevin一直看到的鹿。二是Evie和她的朋友裸体在林间奔跑以及她的癫痫,可能与她失踪的原因有关。
至于开头那很长的一段史前人类的情景,每当鹰击长空之时,就有转折发生:第一次,山崩,母亲与她的族人分离;第二次,母亲因蛇毒而死,孩子在她怀中无助地哭泣,另一个人走过来,抱走了孩子......
不管有什么艰难险阻,生命就这样延续,人类,就这样,代代相传。
最后一点,也许是为了呼应第一季结尾那看似团圆的结局,这一季的BGM,除了那首忧伤的钢琴曲,风格总体还是偏向欢快类型的,然而,更欢快的音乐,企图掩盖的,是不是更深、更痛的悲伤呢?
5 ) 脸书上看的评论 大家看看
“It all makes sense now. Virgil (the older Black man in the trailer), was actually Erika's father, and not John's. Virgil sexually assaulted Evie when she was around 10 years old, and her mother Erica did not want to believe it was happening (perhaps she was also abused by him as a child, and so she was in denial about his predatory nature). Still in denial about the abuse, Erika did not do anything to protect Evie, and this is why Evie felt detached from her family and resentful towards her mother... and eventually why she decided to join Meg and the Guilty Remant, because she bonded with Meg for having a similar hatred for their mothers. This is also why Evie wrote on the bridge that her mother understood why she was doing all this (because of Erika's apathy and denial during Evie's childhood abuse). 6 years ago, John found out about Erika's father abusing Evie and then shot him, and so then John went to prison for the attempted murder of his father-in-law. John had been filled with rage ever since... not just towards Virgil (his father-in-law) for the abuse... but also towards Erika (his wife) for not doing enough to protect their daughter from Virgil. Erika was so detached and disallusioned from that tragedy, that she was going to leave her family and take off because she just couldn't deal with everthing (she told Nora about this during her departure interview). Meg initially joined the Guilty Remnant last year because she was disallusioned with her life and just totally lost... but during her time there, she saw the truth, in that the Guilty Remnant was actually a bullshit cult and wrong about everything, and that the loving bond of family was the ONLY thing that truly mattered. Laurie, indirectly, helped Meg see this by the strong feelings she couldn't hide that she still had for her daughter Jill (the G.R. was teaching everyone the opposite, in that they said nothing mattered, as the world had ended on 10/14). Meg figured out that the G.R. was a fraud and decided to take control of her branch of the group and do things her own way, and it was then that she planned this grand gesture in Jarden Texas to get people to wake up and see what really mattered to them... and she did this thru the bomb scare on the bridge...and by doing so, she also enabled all the lost people trapped in the campgrounds to have the freedom to move into the town as they had been so desperate to do for as long as they had been there (she hated the hypocrisy of the privileged town's people). She made a similar gesture towards Tom earlier in the season, as she tried to scare him back into caring about what really mattered to him (his family), when she raped him (to get him "pregnant", by planting the seed of realization of the truth), and by scaring him to death, by pretending to douse him with gasoline. She did all these thngs to scare people out of their tortured misery and apathy, and back into the reality of what really mattered - the love for the people most close to them in their lives (their family). If the series is renewed for a 3rd season, then I fully expect it will focus primarily on the Murphys (John, Erika, Michael, and Evie), and less on Kevin and his family, as his demons have been vanquished. He literally went to Hell and back again (twice) to find his way back home to his family, and so his story is finally resolved. Kevin finally feels grounded and at peace with what happened on 4 years earlier on October 14th, and so he is no longer suicidal or afraid... and finally able to allow himself to love, and be loved in return. He has been reborn.”
6 ) 第七集有一瞬间好可怜男主
K:Would you believe me?
N:I would believe you.
K:And would you come back?
N:I'd like that.
最后一集还没看到,但这不影响我对它的五星好评。应该说是一部很合我胃口的剧,每一集基调都很“沉闷”,没有什么笑点,也正是这样,避开了现在大部分电视剧都偏俗气的现象。从这部剧里面不仅看到了精彩的剧情,还看到了角色的心灵和信仰,主题也因此升华到灵魂的高度,这是毫不夸大的言辞。
第二季的变奏让人想到双峰镇,而变奏中的“酒店”就好像达蒙·林德洛夫写给闪灵的情诗。(208mark)
第二季的[守望尘世]质量有着飞跃式地增长,这也许和它整季的结构有关:这是一个关于人造的圣地逐步垮塌的寓言。在聚焦单个人、发展每个人独一无二的应对措施的同时,能够在宏观走向上保持一步一个脚印、却又不特定按时间顺序。里面的奇幻部分天马行空又不至于脱缰。只是结尾处出现庸俗的腔调。
依旧是今年的最佳。
转变了基调本剧依然强大,这回成为了重建/悲伤/毁灭的复合体。延续已有设定,并且延续了重重谜团。谜团的存在的意义并非在于解开,而在于让人铭记真正重要的东西的价值。Yes, make them see, make them remember.
There are no miracles in Miracle.
一定要会唱歌
第三集Peter对Laurie的评价一针见血, 突然间这个女人伪善的面具被撕掉,这个女人很disgusting, selfish, and cold. 不管是对Jill , Kevin 还是他儿子. She destroyed them and their lives.
不枉我从S1开始力推贵剧。//众生皆苦。No one is spared. 面对这未知的世界,不要苦求什么答案。Let the mystery be. 这集finale太棒了,宗教哲学隐喻太值得剖析了。可惜和 Fargo 一样,到最后依旧是美式家庭至上价值观。
All adults fucked up... 第一季还遵从些许小说影子,这季完全把小说丢弃。所有人物都开始乱抽。还从头到尾不间断性fucked up. 第一季结尾多完美。
OMGOMGOMGOMG
比第一季简直是云泥之别
季终集IMDB 9.8分 吓尿………这个结局可以当做大结局了 当然故事还可以继续 evie为什么这么做?kevin为什么可以无限复活?地震到底是?为什么?
第二季比第一季精彩的剧有吗?我想了半天也想不起来,我看的时候一直在想,到底是什么样的人喜欢这种剧,导演为什么要拍这种注定关注度会很低的剧,我每天两集的看,实在是舍不得看完!如果,美是生命意识在感受到自身脆弱不堪时的颤栗,那么,这是一部美剧,更是一部神剧!我是多么的期待第三季啊!
虽然仍和第一季同路地依托于小镇之上,但第二季其实与第一季在气质上是脱节的。人物用一种更暴烈、激动的方式活着,且原始的设定也不再那么紧扣,进行诸多变奏。末日荒诞气息的“奇迹小镇”给剧的世界观“圈地”,陷入进“类乌托邦”叙事。随之情节冲突愈发强烈,达到一种表面看起来野心更大,实际上只是观赏性强的效果。但仍是美剧中的顶级水准吧。
有时候就需要相信神启。
演技一流,节奏缓慢到位,hotel的设定简直颠覆,立意太深i still don't understand。结局也不算什么大阴谋啊,外界的躁乱,野蛮人的狂欢,家庭的羁绊。加一句,男主颜值耐看演技还了不得力荐力荐。
拍个电视剧还拍的那么装逼难懂,便秘一般感觉的男主角总是挤不尽挤不出了
挺喜欢第一季,但也完全没想到脱离原著后的林德洛夫在第二季中超水平发挥,硬生生把这剧写成了《迷失》的高逼格兄弟篇。前几集过渡后便高能不断,56789集集高水准,剧本滴水不漏的完美。收尾仓促了点,估计也没料到会有第三季。
这部剧的第一季就有一种神秘的粘稠感,非常优秀,可能过于高冷让很多人错过了。第一季的评分其实仍然是严重偏低的。第二季的开头音乐太让人错乱了。轻快得像个喜剧。开头的部分也很怪异。越往后看渐入佳境。不知道这一季是第一季的前传,还是有另外的设定。腔调满满,逼格闪闪。